fbpx
Beat Inertia - Learn the Science of Change
Escaping the App Trap  
WITH: Laurie Santos
SOURCE: Why You're Still Using Social Media
PUBLISHED: November 1, 2026
• Beat Inertia - Learn the Science of Change

Sources

Why It’s Worth It │ Would you actually pay real money for the app you spent four hours in yesterday? If the honest answer is no, why does the thought of quitting feel so off-putting? Spoiler alert: quitting apps that deplete our precious free time may not be a question of willpower after all. 

In this episode of The Happiness Lab, host Laurie Santos talks with Cass Sunstein about an idea new enough that it barely has a literature yet. Writing for this year’s World Happiness Report, Cass gives a name to something many of us have felt without being able to describe it: the category of goods we consume while quietly wishing they did not exist. He calls them product traps, and once we have the phrase, they turn up everywhere.

Most purchases work the way economics expects. Large classes of goods such as countertop appliances are a great example here. Whether a blender is worth its price tag depends on how well it crushes ice and how easily it cleans. But a small class of goods breaks that rule. In this case, value depends on who else is using the good and, more pointedly, on what happens to us if we do not.

That second part is the trap. Cass frames the cost as landing on the person who abstains. Declining a party invite signals something about us. Being the only parent who skips a holiday tradition the other children are enjoying costs something. Cass offers a family example that cuts the other way: his sister proposed that the adults stop exchanging Christmas gifts, and everyone was relieved because this new proposal relieved everyone of the pressure to find the perfect gift. 

Laurie has a similar analogy. The students she teaches point to homework and the use of LLMs to get it done. Most of them know they are cutting corners and the result will not be as good, but believing that everyone else is using AI is often too strong a siren call to resist. 

Then Cass brings the evidence, and it is genuinely strange. He asked one group how much they would pay monthly to access a given platform, and another how much they would demand to stay off the same platform for a month. A Nobel Prize-winning study suggests that the willingness to pay for a service should match its cost, but in this case, it did not. Many users expressed they were unwilling to pay anything, while others offered between $5 and $10. In contrast, to give up access, they expected $100 in compensation, revealing a discrepancy of roughly 20-to-1, rather than the predicted 1-to-1 ratio.

Another team went further and actually paid people to leave a platform for a month. Those people had a good month by every measure, reporting greater life satisfaction and less anxiety. Then they were asked again what it would take to stay off. Having just lived the answer, they should have said nothing. They said eighty-six dollars.

The question that finally cracked it was a small change in wording. How much would you demand to be off, if everyone in your community were off as well? At that point the sums invert. People say they would pay. The true finding? People don’t seem to want the platforms at all. They just don’t want to be left out. 

Background │ In this episode, Laurie speaks with Cass Sunstein, a professor at Harvard who works on law and behavioral science, co-author of Nudge, and a contributor to this year’s World Happiness Report. Key takeaways include:

  • What a product trap is: A good we buy or use because of what happens if we do not, rather than because of anything we get from it. We would often prefer a world without it.
  • The cost falls on the abstainer: Groups that pile into goods impose a silent penalty on whoever opts out, which is why the decision not to join feels costly. 
  • Loss aversion supplies the fuel: Missing out registers as a loss, and losses land roughly twice as hard as equivalent gains. That asymmetry is what makes the trap hold.
  • The 20-to-1 gap: We usually pay nothing to use these platforms yet demand a great deal ($$$) to leave them. Economic theory says those numbers should be identical.
  • Experience does not release us: People paid to leave for a month felt measurably better but still wanted to be paid to stay away afterward. Knowing something is bad for us changes the arithmetic less than we would hope.
  • The wording that reveals it: Asked how much ($$$) it would take to leave while everyone else stayed, people name a price. Asked what they would want if everyone left together, they offer to pay.
  • Escape is collective: Individual willpower is the wrong tool. Group agreements, school policies, and shared norms are what actually work, and naming the trap is the first move.

About | Laurie Santos is a Yale professor, researcher, and happiness expert who studies how psychology can guide us to make better choices and live happier, more fulfilling lives. Her course on happiness, the most popular course at Yale in over 300 years, is offered in an online version, The Science of Well-Being, on Coursera. Laurie also hosts The Happiness Lab, a podcast that focuses on changing how we think about happiness. Laurie’s core belief is simple: What our minds tell us will make us happy is often a lie.

Source | The Happiness Lab: Why You’re Still Using Social Media (March 23, 2026)

More Resources

Regulating Hard Feelings 

Regulating Hard Feelings 

Why It's Worth It │ When did any of us actually learn what to do with a hard feeling? It feels like we have all just muddled along improvising as we go, surviving situations where our default strategies often only make things worse. What if there are so many more...

Boosting Creativity

Boosting Creativity

Why It's Worth It │ What if the thing standing between us and our best work is not a shortage of freedom but too much of it? What would we actually make if someone took away our usual options? And why does a blank page feel so much harder than one that already...

Harnessing Your Energy 

Harnessing Your Energy 

Why It's Worth It | Why do we keep pushing harder at the exact things that aren't working? How much of our energy goes toward the right things, and how much quietly drains away into habits, avoidances, and strengths that have quietly turned against us? And what...

Laurie Santos

Want More From

Laurie Santos ?

Right this way…

Chart Your Path

Want to get going? We’ve created a straightforward chart to help clarify goals and track steps for the week ahead.