fbpx
Beat Inertia - Get Started
Becoming Truly Skilled  
WITH: Katy Milkman
SOURCE: To Know What You Know
PUBLISHED: May 15, 2025
• Beat Inertia - Get Started

Sources

Why It’s Worth It | Ever thought you nailed something only to have it comically backfire? Like that time you were sure you could install your own smart doorbell, yet ended up with a big hole in the wall and a hefty bill from the electrician? Or maybe you left an interview feeling like a rockstar just to get hit with a “thanks, but no thanks” email? There’s a wild psychological twist behind why we often feel super confident right when we should be cautious.

Enter Katy Milkman, who hosts the Choiceology podcast by Charles Schwab, where she digs into the psychology and economics of decision-making. In this episode, she explores the Dunning-Kruger effect with special guests Andrew Flack, a librettist known for his opera “Behold the Man,” and David Dunning himself, the psychologist who co-discovered this mind-blowing phenomenon.

Katy always uses real-life stories to help illustrate her science, and this episode kicks off with a quick story about thieves who were tracked and caught because of the very thing they had stolen (GPS trackers which could be used remotely, no less!) before turning to the more dramatic tale of Cecilia Giménez. In 2012, Cecilia, an elderly Spanish lady with no professional art restoration training, decided to fix a church fresco of Jesus in Borja, Spain. Her confidence led to a botched restoration and an internet sensation, spawning memes galore. (But don’t worry—Cecilia made it to the other “good” side of the fame cycle—what started as a visual disaster turned into a tourist boom for her town).

Cecilia’s journey perfectly captures Katy’s topic du jour: the Dunning-Kruger effect, the name for the all-too-common phenomenon that occurs when people without expertise implausibly believe they can expertly tackle something hard. Through his research with Justin Kruger, David found that students who flunked logic tests couldn’t accurately gauge their performance, even when money was on the line. In another jaw-dropping example, medical residents bombing their OBGYN rotation thought they were acing it.

David points out that this effect is different from plain old overconfidence because it specifically involves skill assessment—being less skilled often means you’re less able to judge how actaully skilled you are. When we lack the ability to assess ourselves accurately, our judgments frequently skew towards unwarranted optimism and (too often than not) an unpleasant awakening.

The Dunning-Kruger effect is all around us, all the time. One of best defenses is to prepare, prepare, prepare and to collaborate and seek input from others. Swashbuckling confidence is a fool’s delight (and a waste of time really), while pragmatic, thorough study and consultation will win the day if we persist. 

Background | In this episode, Katy speaks with Andrew Flack, a librettist who transformed the viral story of a botched fresco restoration into an acclaimed comic opera “Behold the Man” (in collab with composer Paul Fowler), and David Dunning, a pioneering social psychologist and professor at the University of Michigan who (in collab with professor Justin Kruger) identified the now-famous Dunning-Kruger effect through groundbreaking research on how people assess their own competence. Key insights include:

  • The Dunning-Kruger effect is everywhere: It hits all of us, no matter how smart or experienced we are. This isn’t about personal failings; it’s a fundamental quirk of human cognition that affects everything from picking houses to electing leaders.
  • Preparation is your secret weapon: David advocates that the best game plan is to focus more on preparation. He suggests leaning into pessimism while planning and then confidence when it’s go-time.
  • Spotting expertise is crucial: We can’t judge our skills well without expertise, so it’s vital to tread carefully when just starting out.
  • Get second opinions: Consulting others, especially on important matters, helps cover our blind spots in self-evaluation.
  • Pad estimates: We should bump up our initial guesses when estimating anything outside of our wheelhouse. This helps counter the natural tendency to underestimate in new territories.
  • Be ready to pivot: Staying open to mistakes and willing to adjust course combats blind confidence.
  • Humility can be a game-changer: Remember, when we have a skill gap, the likelihood we will whiff goes up. Acknowledging this can lead to smarter decisions and fewer blunders.

Source | Choiceology: To Know What You Know- Season 14, Episode 2 (August 28, 2024)

About|  Katy Milkman is a behavioral scientist, Wharton professor, national bestselling author, and host of Choiceology, a Charles Schwab original podcast that melds conversations about science, research, and human quirks to help us make better decisions and avoid costly mistakes. She also produces an insightful free newsletter, Milkman Delivers (sign up on her website!). Katy believes the key to changing ourselves for good lies in better understanding the internal obstacles that hold us back. 

More Resources

Escaping the App Trap  

Escaping the App Trap  

Why It's Worth It │ Would you actually pay real money for the app you spent four hours in yesterday? If the honest answer is no, why does the thought of quitting feel so off-putting? Spoiler alert: quitting apps that deplete our precious free time may not be a...

Regulating Hard Feelings 

Regulating Hard Feelings 

Why It's Worth It │ When did any of us actually learn what to do with a hard feeling? It feels like we have all just muddled along improvising as we go, surviving situations where our default strategies often only make things worse. What if there are so many more...

Boosting Creativity

Boosting Creativity

Why It's Worth It │ What if the thing standing between us and our best work is not a shortage of freedom but too much of it? What would we actually make if someone took away our usual options? And why does a blank page feel so much harder than one that already...

Laurie Santos

Want More From

Katy Milkman ?

Right this way…

Chart Your Path

Want to get going? We’ve created a straightforward chart to help clarify goals and track steps for the week ahead.